Smith College vs Macalester College

Smith College and Macalester College, two esteemed institutions of higher learning, offer distinct educational experiences. Smith, a women's college in Northampton, Massachusetts, boasts a 44% acceptance rate and a student body of over 2,600 undergraduates. Macalester, a coeducational college in Saint Paul, Minnesota, has a slightly higher acceptance rate of 48% and a more diverse student body of around 2,000 undergraduates. Both colleges excel in liberal arts education, with popular majors including social sciences, humanities, and natural sciences. However, Smith offers a wider range of majors in the arts, while Macalester is known for its strong international studies and environmental studies programs. Explore the detailed comparison table below to discover more about these colleges' unique strengths and determine which one aligns best with your academic aspirations and personal preferences.
Macalester College logo

Macalester College

Smith College logo

Smith College

Overview

Location Saint Paul, Minnesota Northampton, Massachusetts
Campus setting City: Large Suburb: Large
College type 4 year 4 year
Control/business model Private (Non Profit) Private (Non Profit)
Calendar system Semester Semester
Degrees offered Undergraduate Undergraduate and Graduate
Students retention rate 96.0% 95.0%
Common app member No Yes
Religious affiliation Presbyterian

Admission

Acceptance rate 31.3% 29.9%
Application fees $40 $60
SAT range 1340 - 1515 1370 - 1530
ACT range 29 - 33 31 - 34
Students submitting SAT score 35.0% 34.0%
Students submitting ACT score 39.0% 20.0%
Total number of applicants 9,046 6,064
Total number of admissions given out 2,828 1,814
Admitted students who chose to enroll 601 676
Yield rate 21.3% 37.3%
Test scores (SAT/ACT) N/A N/A
High school GPA Not required Not required
Recommendation letters Required Required
High school transcript Not required Not required
English proficiency test (e.g. TOEFL) Required Not required

Tuition and Fees

Sticker price $76,357 $68,128
Average net price $30,939 $29,569
Tuition $60,288 $55,830
Room & board
Room/dormitory: $7,272

Meal plan: $6,270
Room/dormitory: $9,700

Meal plan: $9,720
Available payment plans
  • Tuition payment plan
  • Prepaid tuition plan
  • Tuition payment plan

Financial Aid

Students receiving financial aid

(Grants & scholarships)

87.0%
Average amount $42,832
70.0%
Average amount $44,108
Students receiving federal student loan 39.0%
Average amount $4,799
35.0%
Average amount $3,560
Students taking out private loans 29.0%
Average amount $4,321
5.0%
Average amount $8,280

Students and Campus

Undergraduate students 2,244
Men 43.3% Women 56.7%
2,566
Men 0.1% Women 99.9%
Graduate students N/A 358
Men 16.2% Women 83.8%
Racial/ethnic diversity
Low
Moderate
Out-of-state students N/A N/A
International students 13.5% 13.4%
Campus local/setting City: Large Suburb: Large
Dormitory capacity 1,332 2,519
First year students are required to live on campus? Yes No
Top 5 states where most U.S. students come from N/A Mississippi New York California Connecticut Maryland

Academics

Popular study areas
  • Mathematics and Statistics
  • Foreign Languages and Literatures
  • Multidisciplinary Studies
  • Social Sciences
  • Computer and Information Science
  • Public Administration and Social Service
  • Engineering
  • Social Sciences
  • Foreign Languages and Literatures
  • Mathematics and Statistics
Students to faculty ratio 10:1 9:1
Institutional accreditation Higher Learning Commission New England Commission on Higher Education

Outcome

Graduation rate 89.7% 91.0%
Dropout rate 10.0% 3.6%
Transferred out N/A 5.1%
Alumni salary by major (Top 10)
Economics (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $47,163
  • Year 2: $64,493
  • Year 3: $72,135
Mathematics (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $60,896
  • Year 2: $52,107
  • Year 3: $56,193
Political Science and Government (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $28,635
  • Year 2: $35,274
  • Year 3: $43,620
Geography and Cartography (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $28,253
  • Year 2: $32,569
  • Year 3: $39,047
International/Global Studies (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $22,368
  • Year 2: $34,526
  • Year 3: $36,933
Psychology, General (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $24,116
  • Year 2: $31,133
  • Year 3: $34,521
Natural Resources Conservation and Research (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $26,444
  • Year 2: N/A
  • Year 3: N/A
Communication and Media Studies (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: N/A
  • Year 2: $21,508
  • Year 3: N/A
Computer and Information Sciences, General (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $73,129
  • Year 2: $71,575
  • Year 3: N/A
Education, General (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: N/A
  • Year 2: $33,281
  • Year 3: N/A
Engineering, General (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $62,496
  • Year 2: N/A
  • Year 3: $70,990
Economics (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: N/A
  • Year 2: $47,650
  • Year 3: $56,651
Social Work (Master's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $48,011
  • Year 2: $45,554
  • Year 3: $53,962
Liberal Arts and Sciences, General Studies and Humanities (Master's Degrees)
  • Year 1: N/A
  • Year 2: $46,620
  • Year 3: $53,886
Education, General (Master's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $42,098
  • Year 2: $43,798
  • Year 3: $48,619
Political Science and Government (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $40,776
  • Year 2: $39,153
  • Year 3: $43,120
Education, General (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: N/A
  • Year 2: $31,839
  • Year 3: $41,147
Research and Experimental Psychology (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $29,006
  • Year 2: $18,566
  • Year 3: $41,145
Romance Languages, Literatures, and Linguistics (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $26,954
  • Year 2: $28,019
  • Year 3: $40,411
Neurobiology and Neurosciences (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: N/A
  • Year 2: $34,603
  • Year 3: $38,497

Frequently Asked Questions


  • What are the key differences between Smith College and Macalester College?

    Smith College is a historically women's college located in Northampton, Massachusetts, known for its strong liberal arts focus and commitment to women's education. Macalester College, located in Saint Paul, Minnesota, is a coeducational liberal arts college with a strong emphasis on internationalism, civic engagement, and social justice. Smith offers a more traditional single-sex college experience, while Macalester provides a coeducational environment with a global perspective.

  • How do the academic programs at Smith and Macalester compare?

    Both Smith and Macalester offer a wide range of liberal arts programs. Smith is particularly strong in the humanities, arts, and sciences, with notable programs in engineering and performing arts. Macalester excels in international studies, political science, economics, and environmental studies. While both emphasize interdisciplinary learning, Macalester's curriculum often incorporates a global or social justice lens.

  • What is the campus environment like at each college?

    Smith College boasts a beautiful, traditional campus with a strong sense of community fostered by its house system. The campus is located in a vibrant college town with access to the Five College Consortium. Macalester's campus is located in a residential neighborhood of Saint Paul, offering a more urban feel and easy access to the Twin Cities' cultural and professional opportunities. Macalester's campus culture is known for its activism and engagement with social issues.

  • How do the student bodies at Smith and Macalester differ?

    Smith College primarily enrolls women, creating a unique and empowering academic environment. Macalester College is coeducational and attracts a diverse student body from across the United States and around the world, with a significant percentage of international students. Both colleges attract academically strong and intellectually curious students, but Macalester tends to have a higher percentage of students interested in international affairs and social justice.

  • What are the career services and opportunities like at Smith and Macalester?

    Both Smith and Macalester offer comprehensive career services, including advising, internships, and networking opportunities. Smith benefits from its strong alumnae network, which provides valuable connections and mentorship for students. Macalester leverages its location in the Twin Cities to offer internships and career opportunities in a variety of fields, particularly in business, non-profit, and government sectors. Both colleges prepare students for graduate school and a wide range of professional careers.

  • What is the cost of attendance and financial aid situation at Smith and Macalester?

    The cost of attendance at both Smith and Macalester is comparable, and both institutions are committed to meeting the demonstrated financial need of their students. Both offer a range of financial aid options, including grants, scholarships, and loans. It's best to visit their respective financial aid websites and use their net price calculators to get a personalized estimate of the cost of attendance based on your family's financial situation.

  • What are the advantages of attending a women's college like Smith versus a coeducational college like Macalester?

    Attending a women's college like Smith can provide a supportive and empowering environment where women can thrive academically and develop leadership skills without gender-based stereotypes. A coeducational college like Macalester offers a more diverse social environment and prepares students for working in mixed-gender settings. The best choice depends on your individual learning style and preferences.

  • How do the locations of Smith and Macalester impact the student experience?

    Smith College's location in Northampton, Massachusetts, offers a quintessential New England college town experience with a strong arts and culture scene. The Five College Consortium provides access to courses and resources at Amherst, Mount Holyoke, Hampshire, and UMass Amherst. Macalester's location in Saint Paul, Minnesota, provides access to the vibrant Twin Cities metropolitan area, with its diverse cultural attractions, professional opportunities, and thriving arts scene. The urban setting offers a different kind of college experience, with more opportunities for engagement with the wider community.

  • What are some notable alumni from Smith College and Macalester College?

    Smith College boasts a distinguished alumnae network including Barbara Bush (former First Lady), Gloria Steinem (feminist activist), and Julia Child (chef and author). Macalester College's notable alumni include Kofi Annan (former Secretary-General of the United Nations), Walter Mondale (former Vice President of the United States), and Tim O'Brien (author). These alumni reflect the colleges' respective strengths in leadership, public service, and the arts.

  • How do Smith and Macalester approach diversity and inclusion?

    Both Smith and Macalester are committed to diversity and inclusion, but they approach it in different ways. Smith focuses on creating an inclusive environment for women from diverse backgrounds. Macalester emphasizes global perspectives and social justice, actively recruiting students from around the world and promoting dialogue on issues of equity and inclusion. Both colleges have programs and initiatives designed to support students from underrepresented groups.

Compare Similar Colleges

The list of suggested college comparisons provided below is generated automatically by our system, utilizing statistics gathered from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) and various online sources. If you don't find the colleges you wish to compare, please visit our comparison page. There, you can search for the specific colleges and initiate your comparison.
Macalester College Macalester College vs Occidental College Occidental College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Pepperdine University Pepperdine University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Pitzer College Pitzer College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Scripps College Scripps College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Colorado College Colorado College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Connecticut College Connecticut College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Trinity College Trinity College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Wesleyan University Wesleyan University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Rollins College Rollins College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Illinois Wesleyan University Illinois Wesleyan University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Lake Forest College Lake Forest College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Principia College Principia College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Wheaton College Wheaton College
Macalester College Macalester College vs DePauw University DePauw University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Grand View University Grand View University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Grinnell College Grinnell College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Luther College Luther College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Berea College Berea College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Bates College Bates College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Bowdoin College Bowdoin College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Colby College Colby College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Johns Hopkins University Johns Hopkins University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Clark University Clark University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Harvard University Harvard University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Massachusetts Institute of Technology Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Macalester College Macalester College vs Williams College Williams College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Hillsdale College Hillsdale College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Carleton College Carleton College
Macalester College Macalester College vs North Central University North Central University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Saint Mary's University of Minnesota Saint Mary's University of Minnesota
Macalester College Macalester College vs Millsaps College Millsaps College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Dartmouth College Dartmouth College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Bard College Bard College
Macalester College Macalester College vs St Lawrence University St Lawrence University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Duke University Duke University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Denison University Denison University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Lewis & Clark College Lewis & Clark College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Brown University Brown University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Rhodes College Rhodes College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Trinity University Trinity University
Macalester College Macalester College vs Bennington College Bennington College
Macalester College Macalester College vs Virginia Military Institute Virginia Military Institute
Macalester College Macalester College vs Stanford University Stanford University
Smith College Smith College vs Claremont McKenna College Claremont McKenna College
Smith College Smith College vs Mills College Mills College
Smith College Smith College vs Scripps College Scripps College
Smith College Smith College vs Connecticut College Connecticut College
Smith College Smith College vs Trinity College Trinity College
Smith College Smith College vs Wesleyan University Wesleyan University
Smith College Smith College vs Georgetown University Georgetown University
Smith College Smith College vs Spelman College Spelman College
Smith College Smith College vs Grinnell College Grinnell College
Smith College Smith College vs Bowdoin College Bowdoin College
Smith College Smith College vs Colby College Colby College
Smith College Smith College vs Hampshire College Hampshire College
Smith College Smith College vs College of the Holy Cross College of the Holy Cross
Smith College Smith College vs Mount Holyoke College Mount Holyoke College
Smith College Smith College vs Bard College at Simon's Rock Bard College at Simon's Rock
Smith College Smith College vs Hillsdale College Hillsdale College
Smith College Smith College vs Macalester College Macalester College
Smith College Smith College vs Bard College Bard College
Smith College Smith College vs Colgate University Colgate University
Smith College Smith College vs Hamilton College Hamilton College
Smith College Smith College vs Union College Union College
Smith College Smith College vs Davidson College Davidson College
Smith College Smith College vs Elon University Elon University
Smith College Smith College vs Wake Forest University Wake Forest University
Smith College Smith College vs Bucknell University Bucknell University
Smith College Smith College vs Franklin and Marshall College Franklin and Marshall College
Smith College Smith College vs Haverford College Haverford College
Smith College Smith College vs Lafayette College Lafayette College
Smith College Smith College vs Furman University Furman University
Smith College Smith College vs Rhodes College Rhodes College
Smith College Smith College vs Trinity University Trinity University
Smith College Smith College vs University of Richmond University of Richmond
Smith College Smith College vs University of Virginia-Main Campus University of Virginia-Main Campus
Smith College Smith College vs Washington and Lee University Washington and Lee University